Your cart is currently empty!
There’s something addictive about a good murder mystery audio drama. But when you add a full voice cast, sound design, and tight writing, it becomes a complete experience that rivals TV shows. You’re not just listening. You’re there, in the middle of it, piecing things together with every clue. I listen to these audio dramas every night before bed. They are captivating, but also allow me to rest my eyes and help me drift off to sleep.
If you like drama, sharp dialogue, and a little blood on the floor, these five murder mystery audio dramas are worth your time. Each one has a full cast, high production quality, and the kind of storytelling that keeps you hooked episode after episode.
Arden
Arden starts like a true crime podcast. A cold case. A missing woman. Two hosts with very different ideas of how to investigate. But it’s not long before you realize it’s fiction – and much smarter than it first appears.
The show blends mystery, media satire, and character drama. The chemistry between the hosts drives most of the story. One’s methodical. The other follows gut instinct. And as they uncover secrets, the story becomes less about what happened and more about why it matters now.
It’s funny. It’s layered. And it rewards close listening.
If you’re into complex characters and enjoy a mystery that unfolds over time, start with Arden.
Jackie the Ripper
Take everything you know about Jack the Ripper and flip it. Now imagine a woman in modern-day London, inspired by the past, hunting down men she thinks deserve it. That’s Jackie the Ripper.
This podcast is sharp. It blends crime thriller with social commentary. You’ll hear multiple voices, layered soundscapes, and a tight narrative that keeps things moving. It’s violent without being messy. Emotional without being preachy. And it’s one of the funniest shows I’ve ever listened to.
Jackie herself is a fascinating lead. You won’t always agree with her. But you’ll want to know what she does next.
This one is for people who like mystery with an edge – and aren’t afraid to follow the killer’s side of the story. I can guarantee you’ll be hooked after the first couple minutes of this one.
Gather The Suspects
Set in a locked-down Welsh apartment building, Gather The Suspects leans into classic mystery tropes with a modern twist. One of the residents is dead. Everyone else is a suspect. And since they can’t leave, they’ll have to solve it themselves.
It’s funny, fast, and self-aware. The characters bounce off each other with great chemistry. Think Cluedo meets a sitcom. It never takes itself too seriously, but the mystery holds up. You’ll find red herrings, strange behaviour, and shifting alliances.
At only a few episodes long, it’s an easy binge. And if you’ve ever lived in a building with loud neighbours and petty arguments, it’ll feel very real.
Mockery Manor
This one’s set in a 1980s British theme park, which already makes it different. Mockery Manor follows twin sisters who get caught in a web of lies, murder, and secrets hidden behind the cheerful theme park rides.
The tone swings between quirky and dark. It’s fun, but there’s always something sinister under the surface. The soundtrack and voice work are excellent, and the mystery keeps layering in new pieces right up to the end.
You won’t find another murder mystery full cast podcast that looks and sounds quite like this one. It’s stylish, confident, and full of surprises.
Start with season one. You’ll get pulled in fast.
Deadly Manners
Deadly Manners is pure throwback. Think Agatha Christie, but audio. A storm traps a group of wealthy guests in a mansion. One of them ends up dead. The killer must be one of them. Everyone has secrets.
It’s got a huge cast, including Kristen Bell and RuPaul. The sound design is lush. Every door creak, every glass clink – perfectly placed. It’s more theatrical than the others on this list, but that works in its favour. It feels like a stage play brought to life in your ears.
If you like classic structure, tight episodes, and high drama, Deadly Manners will scratch that itch.
Top 5 Full Cast Murder Mystery Audio Dramas
Each of these shows does something different with the murder mystery format. Arden gives you emotional depth. Jackie the Ripper flips the moral script. Gather The Suspects brings humor. Mockery Manor offers style. Deadly Manners sticks to the roots of murder mysteries.
Start anywhere. But once you’ve finished one, you’ll probably want the next. These aren’t just podcasts. They’re full experiences. And they prove that murder sounds even better with a full cast.
