Choosing the Right Murder Mystery Kit

A murder mystery kit is a basically a package that contains all the necessary parts to host a murder mystery game at home. These kits typically include a storyline, character descriptions, clues, guidelines for the host, and sometimes scripts – depending on the type of murder mystery you choose. Some kits also come with additional elements like invitations, costume suggestions, and decorative ideas to enhance the evening. Essentially, these kits serve as a ready-to-go framework for organizing a murder mystery event, providing both the narrative and the logistical tools needed to bring the story to life. The complexity and style of these kits vary, ranging from simple family-friendly plots to more intricate scenarios designed for experienced players. The format of these kits can also differ; some are physical products with printed materials, while others are available as digital downloads that you can print and organize yourself.

The right kit should align with the interests, age group, and skill level of the guests. For example – a kit with a 1920s speakeasy theme might be a hit for a group interested in historical settings, while a more contemporary crime scene scenario would appeal to a larger audience The complexity of the game should also be considered – a group new to murder mystery games might prefer a kit with a straightforward plot and clear instructions, while a more seasoned group might seek a challenging and intricate storyline. Furthermore, the size of the group is an important factor; some kits are designed for small gatherings, while others cater to larger parties. The choice of a kit can significantly influence the atmosphere and flow of the party, making it essential to select one that best fits the dynamics and preferences of your group. Let’s take a look at some of these factors in choosing the right kit:

Choosing the Right Murder Mystery Kit

Consider the Size of Your Group

The number of friends you plan to invite over will influence the type of kit that you need. Murder mystery kits are typically designed with a specific number of participants in mind, each playing a major role in the storyline. For small groups of 6 to 8 people, it’s important to choose a kit that ensures each player has a significant part to play, maintaining engagement and interest throughout the game. These kits often focus on deeper character development and more intricate relationships between characters, which is ideal for smaller, more intimate gatherings where each participant can delve deeply into their role.

For medium-sized groups of 10 to 15 people, there are kits that strike a balance between complexity and manageability. These kits often include a mix of primary and secondary characters, allowing for a dynamic interaction without overwhelming the host or the players. In this setting, some players might take on more prominent roles, while others can enjoy being part of the plot without the pressure of being a key suspect, the murderer or a detective.

Large groups, with 20 or more participants, require kits that are designed to accommodate a crowd. These kits often include additional features like team roles or subplots, ensuring that everyone is involved and contributing to the unfolding mystery. Large group kits tend to be more flexible and are great for parties where guests might be mingling and moving around. The size of your group plays a decisive role in the type of murder mystery kit you should choose, with each kit size offering different structures and roles to best fit small, medium, or large gatherings.

Selecting an Appropriate Theme


The theme of the murder mystery sets the tone and atmosphere for the entire event. The theme should resonate with your group’s interests to aid in maximum enjoyment. To choose the right theme, consider the general interests of your guests. Are they fans of classic literature or historical periods? Do they enjoy contemporary settings or perhaps something more fantastical? Understanding your group’s preferences can guide you towards a theme that will captivate their interest. For example, if your guests are history buffs, a theme set in a specific historical era, like the Roaring Twenties or Medieval times, could be a hit. If they prefer something more modern, a contemporary thriller set in a big city or a high-tech corporate setting might be more appealing. I know that with my friend group, if I chose a historical theme, no one would come, but something modern would definitely be a hit. It’s also worth considering the occasion and setting of your party – a Halloween event might lean towards a spookier theme, while a summer gathering could be perfect for a more light-hearted, outdoor mystery.

Popular themes for murder mystery parties cover a wide range of settings and styles. Vintage themes, such as Victorian London, or a classic old mansion murder mystery, are favorites and you can find various distributors of these kits. These themes often allow for elaborate costumes and decorations, adding to the immersive experience.

Modern themes, on the other hand, might include scenarios like a high-stakes corporate scandal, a celebrity party gone wrong, or a mystery aboard a luxury yacht. These contemporary settings often appeal to those who enjoy more current and relatable contexts. Historical themes can transport players to different eras, such as Ancient Egypt, the Wild West, or the Renaissance, providing a unique backdrop for the mystery and an educational twist. Whichever theme you choose – ensuring it aligns with your guests’ interests and the overall vibe of your group will contribute significantly to the success of your murder mystery party.

Difficulty Level and Complexity

Kits vary widely in complexity – from straightforward plots with clear clues to intricate mysteries with elaborate puzzles and subplots. For groups new to murder mystery games or those looking for a more casual experience, a kit with a simpler storyline and well-defined objectives is ideal. These kits typically provide clear guidance and are easier to follow, which helps keep everyone engaged without feeling overwhelmed. These types of kits are perfect for first-timers.

On the other hand, if your group consists of seasoned players or those who relish a challenge, opting for a kit with a higher level of complexity can provide a more satisfying and stimulating experience. These advanced kits often involve multi-layered plots, subtle clues, and require a higher level of deduction and player interaction, offering a deeper and more immersive gaming experience.

Balancing challenge with enjoyment is key in selecting the right murder mystery kit. A game that is too easy might not hold the interest of your guests, while one that is too complicated could lead to frustration. Consider the problem-solving skills and attention span of your group. A well-chosen kit should provide enough of a challenge to keep the game exciting and engaging but not so difficult that it becomes a source of frustration. It’s also important to think about the dynamics of your group – a kit that encourages collaboration and communication can be a great way to involve everyone, regardless of individual problem-solving skills. Ultimately, the goal is to select a murder mystery kit that strikes the right balance, ensuring a fun, engaging, and memorable experience for all participants.

Age Appropriateness

Murder mystery games can vary significantly in terms of theme, complexity, and content, some of which may be more appropriate for adults, while others are tailored for teens. For adult groups, kits often include more sophisticated themes, complex narratives, and possibly mature content – which are obviously not suitable for younger players. These adult-oriented games may delve into more intricate plots involving affairs, substance-abuse, and complex character backstories. So, if children or teenagers are part of the group, it’s important to choose a kit that is age-appropriate, both in terms of content and difficulty level. These family-friendly kits typically feature lighter themes, simpler puzzles, and a focus on fun and collaborative problem-solving, making them accessible and enjoyable for younger players.

Selecting a kit that is appropriate for all players involves more than just considering the age range; it also requires an understanding of the group’s maturity level and interests. For mixed-age groups, it’s important to find a balance – a game that is engaging enough for adults but still appropriate and understandable for younger players. Some kits are specifically designed with flexibility in mind, offering alternative storylines or adjustable content to suit different age groups. Additionally, it’s beneficial to read through the kit’s description, reviews, and content warnings, if any, to gauge the suitability of the theme and narrative. This careful consideration ensures that all participants can enjoy the experience fully, contributing to a fun and inclusive murder mystery party.

Format of the Kit

You can get murder mystery kits in both physical and digital forms. Physical kits typically come with tangible items such as printed booklets, character cards, clues, and occasionally even decorative elements or props. These kits offer a more traditional and tactile experience, allowing players to physically interact with the game components, which can enhance the immersive aspect of the murder mystery. Physical kits are often preferred for their convenience and ease of use, as everything you need is provided in one package, ready to be used right out of the box. However, they are more expensive than digital versions and may require shipping, which could add to the cost and wait time. Most physical kits will only ship in the same country that they are made in, meaning that your choices are severely limited if you live in the wrong place.

Digital kits, on the other hand, are downloadable versions that you can print and organize yourself. The primary advantage of digital kits is their immediacy and lower cost. They allow for quick access and the flexibility to print as many copies of the game materials as needed. Digital kits are also easier to customize; for instance, you can modify certain elements to better suit your group or the occasion. However, they do require more preparation time, as you’ll need to print, and possibly cut or craft, the game components yourself. This can be a drawback for those who prefer the convenience of a ready-to-use kit. Additionally, the quality of the printed materials will depend on your resources, which might affect the overall aesthetic of your game. If you can print some of the resources on cardstock, instead of paper, it will give your final kit a more professional look. When choosing between a physical and a digital kit, consider factors like budget, preparation time, and the preference for either a ready-made set or a more customizable option.


From considering the size and dynamics of your group to selecting a theme that resonates with all participants – each aspect plays a crucial role in crafting an unforgettable experience. Whether you opt for a physical or digital kit, it’s important to balance the complexity and challenge of the game with the age appropriateness and interests of your guests. By carefully assessing these various factors – you can select a murder mystery kit that not only fits your group’s needs but also enhances the fun and excitement of unraveling a mystery together. With the right kit in hand, you’re well on your way to hosting a memorable, entertaining, and immersive murder mystery party.

Select your currency