Your cart is currently empty!
When it comes to murder mystery parties – I always recommend finger foods.You don’t want guests stuck at the table when they could be solving clues or discussing theories with other party goers. That’s why finger foods are perfect. Quick, tasty, and easy to eat while walking around. Paper plates – no mess, no stress.
Let’s talk about some easy, delicious murder mystery party snacks that everyone can enjoy – without sitting down.
1. Mini Sandwich Skewers
Tiny sandwiches are always a winner. Quick, easy and can be customized with your guests favorite foods.
Just take bread, ham or cheese, maybe a slice of tomato or cucumber, and cut it into small squares. Stack the pieces, and you’re done!
Tip: Use different combos for variety. Some with chicken, some with egg mayo, some with cheese and pickle.
2. Simple Meatballs
For a quick and tasty snack, try out different types of meatballs.
You can use frozen meatballs or make your own. Cook them, stick them on toothpicks, and serve them with a small bowl of dipping sauce—maybe BBQ or sweet chili.
Tip: Want to get fancy? Call them “Bloody Bites” and mix up a bright red sauce for a spooky effect.
3. Puff Pastry Bites
Puff pastry is your best friend for party snacks. Just cut it into small squares, fill with cheese, ham, or spinach, fold them over, and bake.
They’re light, crispy, and will disappear fast from your buffet.
4. Cheesy Sticks
Grab some cheese cubes, olives, or cherry tomatoes. Stick them on cocktail sticks in any order. They look nice and taste even better.
For something a little fancier – use mozzarella balls, cherry tomatoes, and basil. Stick them on a toothpick and drizzle with a little olive oil.
It’s light, fresh, and easy to hold while chasing down suspects.
5. Sausage Rolls
Mini sausage rolls are always a hit. You can make them or buy them ready-made. Cut them small so people can grab one without needing a plate.
Warm them up just before the guests arrive, and they’ll go fast!
6. Wrap-and-Slice Rolls
Take a tortilla wrap, fill it with cream cheese and something tasty—like smoked salmon, ham, or roasted veggies. Roll it up, slice it into bite-sized pieces, and stick in some toothpicks.
These are great cold and are so quick to make.
7. Pizza
The simplest and most classic finger food. Order a few pizzas from your favorite pizzeria and you won’t have to think about catering at all. Just remember to order in advance, so the food doesn’t arrive too late.
8. Fruit Cups
Now onto more dessert-like offerings. Cut up some fruit like pineapples, strawberries, and melon. Put a few pieces in little cups and store in the fridge until guests arrive.
Great for a lighter option between all the savory snacks. Don’t use fruit that spoil quick like bananas.
9. Bags of Popcorn
Easy, cheap, and fun. Put out some bags of popcorn for something super light. You can go classic with salted or caramel corn, or try fun flavors like cheese and chives or ranch.
10. Cookies
For something sweet – buy some of your favorite cookies and put them out on some plates. Those with a sweet tooth will love this.
Tip: If you want to theme your cookies, you can use icing to add question marks, or red icing as fake blood.
Some Extra Tips for a Smooth Night:
- Avoid overly messy sauces—no one wants sticky fingers during an interrogation, or at least have some wet wipes on hand.
- Use napkins, serviettes or paper plates instead of regular plates. Your cleanup will be infinitely faster.
- Label food if needed—especially if some guests don’t eat meat, gluten, or dairy. Keep them in separate containers as well.
Murder Mystery Finger Food Ideas
Murder mystery parties are full of fun, drama, and sometimes – chaos. The food choices should help keep the flow going – and not slow it down. With quick, tasty finger foods, your guests can eat, chat, and keep the game going all at once.
So don’t stress yourself out with a huge 3-course meal – because when it comes to murder mystery dinners, finger foods always get away with it.
