If you enjoy Only Murders in the Building (OMITB), you already know how fun a good murder mystery can be when it mixes good writing, and great actors. The cozy mystery is like comfort food and is endlessly rewatchable. If you’re looking for similar shows, I’ve got you covered. Each one has strong storytelling, plenty of clues, and a chance for you to play detective from your couch.
A murder takes place in the White House and an eccentric detective is called in to solve it. She begins digging through the staff’s lives and slowly building a complex theory about how events took place. It’s a very funny show, that lets you solve the mystery yourself if you pay close attention to everything that’s happening in every episode. It’s one of my favorite shows ever.
A flight attendant wakes up in a hotel room next to a dead passenger from her last flight. She has no memory of what happened and has to slowly retrace her steps to try fill in the gaps. Kaley Cuoco is great in this show. It’s funny and full of twists as you slowly see the timeline play out. There’s a lot flashbacks that help show you the story from both the past and the present. It’s also a show that you can try solve on your own by paying close attention to details.
Sherlock & Daughter is an amazing period setting where he works along his possible daughter against a criminal syndicate. Sherlock shows always have some fun twists and turns, but Sherlock & Daughter does better than any others. It’s very funny and the mystery is logical if you’re watching closely. I love everything Sherlock-related, so this was a must-watch, but even if you’re not a fan – you’ll still enjoy this show.
The Afterparty is about a high school reunion that ends in murder. Each episode retells the same night but through the eyes of a different guest, with every version filmed in a different style – from musical to action to rom-com. This is another show that you can solve yourself if follow every clue closely. It’s really funny and has some amazing acting. If you’ve watched The Residence already, it’s a very similar type of show.
5. Murderville
Murderville is a short, improv-style murder comedy with Will Arnett as the main cast member. Each episode has scripted cast members working alongside a guest star who gets no script, and must improvise through a murder investigation. There are only 6 episodes, but 4 of them are drop-dead hilarious. Actors play their parts with a straight face and push the guest star to improvise to keep the scene moving along. If you listen closely to dialogue and reactions, you can solve every single case on your own.
For dark comedy mystery shows, check out my top 5 comedy mystery shows like Wednesday. For lighter comedic mystery shows, check out top 5 shows like High Potential. For a full range of mystery entertainment across every possible format, see our best murder mystery entertainment guide.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which show is most similar to Only Murders in the Building?
The Afterparty is the closest match in terms of tone. Both shows have a similar concept (one building mystery / one party mystery), a cast of suspects who are all shifty, and funny story. The Afterparty’s multi-perspective storytelling makes it very rewatchable and an extremly fun show.
Is Only Murders in the Building ending after Season 5?
No. Season 5 of OMITB aired in 2025. As of early 2026, a sixth season has already been confirmed. The show is ongoing.
Sherwin has been creating amazing murder mystery case files since 2023 – and he has no plans to ever stop. His cases have earned rave reviews from players around the world, and he’s since expanded into full murder mystery dinner party games. With 10 years of experience under his belt creating digital products, he brings a sharp eye for design and detail to every crime scene he builds.
